Skip to main content

The (not so) crazy story of conspiracy theories in the Middle East

Could the leader of ISIS be Jewish? And was Khomeini in fact a British agent? Researcher Itxaso Dominguez de Olazabal explores a world of conspiracies and finds (some) logic behind the craziness. 


Chances are that while visiting Egypt you’ll hear a disconcerting anecdote whereby a shark attacking a Russian tourist in the coastal town of Sharm al Sheikh had been trained by Mossad. But of course, conspiracy theories are not unique to the Middle East; many of us have grown up with stories such as “Man never landed on the moon” or “Elvis is alive.” No one can however deny that such theories are tremendously popular among Arabs and Persians:


WHEN ANALYZED in detail, conspiracy theories follow a particular pattern. In most cases, they refer to notable events. They also display a dualistic worldview and continuously resort to accusations against Israel and/or the West (both depicted as the great Satan), which, according to the Roman principle cui bono, have every chance to be the main beneficiaries of the region’s misfortunes. On the other hand, they are in effect theories, theories that are not falsifiable and thus cannot be scientifically refuted, making it much harder to fight their existence.

The funny thing is that these theories are not widespread only amongst the “mob.” Renowned intellectual and political figures also endorse them, as is the case with many politicians who still claim that 9/11 was devised in and by the United States. And when it is not the authorities who disclose them, it is the authorities who decline to deny and rather tolerate them, contrary to the usual practice in other countries. This shows the important role the media plays in most cases, gagged by the corresponding regime. Furthermore, social networks allow the most outlandish theory to reach unprecedented levels of diffusion. Unresolved dilemmas such as the 2005 assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri do nothing but stoking rumours and conspiracy theories, thus turning into a catch 22.

Just as war is, according to Clausewitz, the continuation of politics by other means, conspiracy theories are, despite their derisory nature, a political instrument, a useful prism when analyzing the relationship between governments and societies in the Middle East. For citizens, these theories represent a way of expressing their frustration and impotence due to the opacity of decision-making – indeed characteristic of regional governance. At the end of the day, these theories depict the leaders in charge as victims rather than wrongdoers. They are also a valuable instrument of domination, a way to test the loyalty of the public that diverts attention and ensures their commitment and unity against external enemies. Saddam Hussein made a masterful use of such during the Gulf War.
image1415778307-27912-PlaceID-0_s1000x650.jpg
THESE THEORIES describe attacks not against clearly defined leaders, but against populations who have the moral obligation to remain faithful to their nation. And if loyalty is not the immediate aftereffect, citizens feel at least compelled to grant recognition to their leader, the only one who dares to fight the dominant orthodox mindset, to resist the common enemy to the value and strength of the Arab people. Gaddafi's speech before the United Nations General Assembly in 2009 is very illustrative in this sense, strewn with gems like the accusation whereby swine flu was a military attack the ‘developed world’ was to blame for. In view of examples like this, we cannot help but wonder whether some leaders come to believe their wild hypothesis.

"The funny thing is that these theories are not widespread only amongst the 'mob'..."
Resorting to simplistic and orientalist considerations should nonetheless be avoided when it comes to conspiracy theories, since they do not represent a characteristic pathology of the Arab people, it is simply not the means through which they explain - and exonerate - their mistakes. (Authors like Daniel Pipes, for example, attribute their existence to an anti-Western and even undemocratic Arab trend). Conspiracy theories may have been oftentimes nurtured by ignorance, rooted particularly in an insufficient knowledge of history. This is however due to deficiencies in the educational systems of the countries themselves, something their leaders make the most of (a symbolic example here would again be Lebanon). Nevertheless, this is not always the case: as Czeslaw Milosz pointed out in his book ‘The Captive Mind’, referring to the Soviet intellectuals, the main feature of this mentality is that their victims end up being afraid of even thinking for themselves.

Taking into account the weight of history on these populations is vital here. So is never forgetting that in the past they have been, as a matter of fact, silent witnesses of conspiracies, such as the Sykes-Picot agreement, the overthrow of Mossadegh or the 1956 Suez crisis. Mistrust is therefore largely understandable in the face of a West guilty of broken promises and neglect. Not to mention a continuous foreign interference. Lebanon, a country where conspiracy theories have become commonplace, stands today, as it did yesterday, as a symbol of the meddling of most countries in the vicinity.

Arab societies have been raised on the idea of ​​secrecy: regimes, sex, architecture (as evidenced by its high walls), differences between sects and communities... This sort of theories is therefore born out of scepticism towards authority, politicians and the state: being an Arab citizen, you get used to being lied to. And, sometimes, institutional reality is so labyrinthine that resorting to simplistic theories is just easier. Last but not least, conspiracy theories are also emerging as a unifying tendency to changing ideologies – Pan-Arabism, Islamism, Socialism, Africanism – within constantly fractured societies. Czeslaw Milosz also spoke about a certain "comfort" the dream brought to victims of the "captive mind". A consolation, however, that still eludes most citizens in the region.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Migrating

Aunque el título pueda referirse a uns de las varias mudanzas a los que me conocéis personalmente estáis acostumbrados, se refiere simplemente a este humilde blog, que tantas alegrias me ha dado. A partir de ahora podréis encontrar todos mis artículos en la página https://discoveringmena.blog Although the title could well refer to one of the rushed and unpredictable decisions those amongst you who know me are by now you used to, 'migrating' refers here to the new site this humble blog - which has given me so much joy - is moving to. From now on you can find all of my articles on the page https://discoveringmena.blog

Libros, películas, series y una canción para entender Israel

From Beirut to Jerusalem , Thomas Friedman (2002) Este es un libro de referencia a la hora de conocer Israel para muchas de las personas que he conocido cuando he estado en y/o hablado de Oriente Medio. Aunque teniendo en cuenta  en lo que Thomas Friedman se ha convertido , quizás recomendar uno de sus obras no parezca una introducción prometedora. En él, el periodista/comentarista cuenta en primera persona su paso como corresponsal por dos de las ciudades más simbólicas de la región en una época turbulenta como fueron los 80, desgranando en el caso del Líbano las aristas del conflicto que asolaba por aquel entonces el país, y en el caso de Israel las características y divisiones de la sociedad israelí, no únicamente desde el punto de vista ideológico en relación con el conflicto con Palestina, sino teniendo también en cuenta otros condicionantes clave, como puede ser el origen, la práctica religiosa, o las condiciones socioeconómicas.   Un grupo de israelíes celebran con band

East Jerusalemites need to be a priority in any new strategy for the Israel-Palestinian conflict

U.S. President Donald Trump’s December 6th announcement, in which he recognised Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, shed light on the significance and symbolism of the city. The priority of the MEPP is to maintain the viability of the two-state solution with Jerusalem as the future capital of two states. Any formula acceptable to both sides needs a political solution for Jerusalem and its holy places. Palestinian residents of Jerusalem are however increasingly becoming culturally, economically and socially marginalised amid institutional inertia, political and physical separation from the West Bank, as well as demographic pressures. 2017 has been a year brimming with commemorations related in one way or the other to what has come to be known as the Israel/Palestine conflict. Various events cast light on its most intractable issue: Jerusalem. Back in July, East Jerusalemites reunited and joined forces with Palestinians from the rest of the West Bank as a consequence of the crisis over I